MCP Server Security

Best MCP security tool for a regulated audit

For a regulated company that must show which MCP servers ran and what they did, Cisco ranks first in this view. Governance and audit weighs 30 and Discovery 25, because auditors want the record, the per-team policy and a complete list of servers.

Facts read on .

The short answer

Cisco leads the view "A regulated company that must show which MCP servers ran and what they did" at 73.0 of 100. Bay is 10th at 52.5. Cisco is ahead mainly on discovery (7 against 4, worth 7.5 points at weight 25).

Why these weights

Auditors want the record, so the audit log and per-team policy weigh most after discovery.

Weights used in this view
DiscoveryVetting before useRuntime control of tool callsDeploymentGovernance and auditTransparencyProof
25151553055
A regulated company that must show which MCP servers ran and what they did: scores out of 10 per criterion, totals out of 100
RankVendorTotal (of 100)Discovery (weight 25)Vetting before use (weight 15)Runtime control of tool calls (weight 15)Deployment (weight 5)Governance and audit (weight 30)Transparency (weight 5)Proof (weight 5)
1stCisco73.07868876
2ndHarmonic Security72.58588846
3rdSnyk (Agent Scan, Evo ADS)67.08968498
4thLasso Security61.56664747
joint 5thBackslash Security60.06765646
joint 5thKnostic60.06757665
7thMicrosoft54.08246586
joint 8thNoma Security53.06654536
joint 8thPillar Security53.06666446
10thBay52.54466707
11thZenity47.55363537
12thCrowdStrike42.54336547
13thSentinelOne (Prompt Security)35.04334346
14thKoi34.04526218

Re-rank with your own weights

The ranking above is the published one. Sliders appear here when scripts run; they start at the published weights and show what your weights would give, without changing the published ranking. Restore the published weights.

What would change this ranking

Top pair. Harmonic Security rising from 8 to 9 on governance and audit (weight 30, so each point moves a total by 3.0) would put Harmonic Security above Cisco; the gap is 0.5 points.

Bay's next place. Bay rising from 7 to 8 on governance and audit (weight 30, so each point moves a total by 3.0) would put Bay above Pillar Security; the gap is 0.5 points.

A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and the weights were fixed before the scores. The method page lists the weights, anchors and rules.

Which tool suits a regulated audit of MCP servers?

Cisco ranks first in this view. Auditors want the record, so Governance and audit weighs 30, with Discovery 25, Vetting 15, Runtime 15, Deployment 5, and Transparency and Proof 5 each.

Governance scores reward policy per team or server, an audit log of servers and tool calls, and export to a SIEM. A log that lives only in the vendor console scores below one that exports in an open format.

What does an auditor ask for?

Typical requests are a list of servers in use on a date, who approved each, the calls made and who made them. The audit logging guide lists the fields to record and the trade-offs on retention.

Retention differs by product. One vendor documents a fixed seven-day period for its agent governance data, so a longer record needs an export.

What would change this view?

Documented SIEM export and per-team scoping would raise several Governance scores that sit at 2 to 5 today. A published retention setting would help buyers who must keep records for a fixed period.