Cisco MCP security: MCP Scanner and AI Defense
Cisco's MCP Scanner is Apache-2.0 open-source code that combines the AI Defense inspect API, YARA rules and LLM-based analysis. Its known-configs mode reads the well-known client config locations on a machine, including Windsurf, Cursor, Claude and VS Code, then scans each server's tools, prompts, resources and instructions. Cisco's hooks apply allow, ask or block decisions to tool calls, with user or group policy, recorded decisions and OpenTelemetry export documented; installs run from the command line or an MDM package on Linux, macOS and Windows. Gaps on 16 Nov 2026: a fleet inventory, an approved-server registry on the machine, per-call inspection of MCP tool arguments, and a published price for paid AI Defense are none found.
Facts read on .
Strength and weakness for MCP Server Security
Strength: A free Apache-2.0 scanner that reads known client configs and scans server tools, prompts, resources, packages and code before use (cisco-21, cisco-22, cisco-24, cisco-30).
Weakness: None found on 2026-11-16 for per-call MCP argument inspection or an approved-server registry on the machine (cisco-36, cisco-31).
Scores and evidence
Cisco is 2nd in the overall ranking at 71.5 of 100. Each score below lists the fact ids behind it; the facts follow further down with their sources and read dates.
| Criterion | Score | Weight | Why | Facts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Discovery | 7 of 10 | 25 | The open-source scanner reads configs for Windsurf, Cursor, Claude and VS Code and scans the tools found; a fleet inventory and Claude Code configs: none found. | cisco-24, cisco-25, cisco-33, cisco-30 |
| Vetting before use | 8 of 10 | 20 | The vendor scans tools, prompts and packages with YARA and LLM analysis at install, and third-party press confirms scanning and server blocking. | cisco-21, cisco-22, cisco-23, cisco-34, cisco-31, cisco-33 |
| Runtime control of tool calls | 6 of 10 | 20 | Hooks check tool calls with allow, ask or block, and third-party press confirms server blocking; inspection of MCP tool-call arguments specifically: none found. | cisco-10, cisco-12, cisco-31, cisco-32, cisco-36 |
| Deployment | 8 of 10 | 15 | Command-line and MDM-package installs on Linux, macOS and Windows, with a five-minute install reported by a third party. | cisco-11, cisco-27, cisco-38, cisco-33 |
| Governance and audit | 8 of 10 | 5 | User or group policy, recorded decisions and OpenTelemetry export are documented, and a third party reports a SIEM connector. | cisco-16, cisco-17, cisco-18, cisco-35, cisco-37 |
| Transparency | 7 of 10 | 10 | Public documentation and observed Apache-2.0 open-source code; a paid price: none found. | cisco-29, cisco-30, cisco-56 |
| Proof | 6 of 10 | 5 | A public company with third-party launch coverage and one named customer voice; analyst coverage for this product: none found. | cisco-60, cisco-58, cisco-59 |
Where it ranks
Product, deployment, price and owner
- Product assessed: Open-source Cisco MCP Scanner (cisco-ai-defense/mcp-scanner) and DefenseClaw skill, plugin and MCP server scanning
- Deployment: Network-level enforcement without agents or libraries for AI Defense; Kong plugin, Python SDK, command-line MCP Scanner, and DefenseClaw hooks installed per user or by MDM package
- Time to deploy: Cisco says DefenseClaw installs in about five minutes (SiliconANGLE); none found on 2026-11-16 for AI Defense
- Price: none found on 2026-11-16 (paid AI Defense); Explorer Edition is described as free
- Owner: Cisco Systems, Inc.
- Website: cisco.com
Facts and sources
cisco-01 (vendor): Cisco Systems, Inc. is the owner and copyright holder of DefenseClaw, the open-source agent governance layer published in the cisco-ai-defense GitHub organization alongside AI Defense.
The exact quote is on the source page.
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-04 (vendor): Cisco says AI Defense enforces at the network level, with no agents or libraries needed on the application side.
Quote: "Cisco enforces AI security at the network-level without the need for agents or libraries."
Source: cisco.com, read .
cisco-10 (vendor): DefenseClaw documentation says its guardrail checks a prompt, a shell command or a tool call before the agent acts and answers allow, alert, ask or block.
Quote: "The guardrail checks what your agent is about to do (a prompt, a shell command, a tool call) against rules, and answers allow, alert, ask you, or block."
Source: cisco-ai-defense.github.io, read .
cisco-11 (vendor): DefenseClaw documentation says support on Linux, macOS and Windows is marked Supported only after a live test verified hooks and a block before the tool call ran.
Quote: "means a live test on that OS verified the agent's hooks and a block before the tool call ran."
Source: cisco-ai-defense.github.io, read .
cisco-12 (vendor): The DefenseClaw compatibility table lists hook contracts for Claude Code that inspect prompts, tool calls and tool results, with similar rows for Codex, Cursor, GitHub Copilot CLI and others.
Quote: "Claude Code | `>=2.1.154, <2.1.219` | `claudecode-hooks-v1` / `v7` | 28 | prompt, tool_call, tool_result, event_content"
Source: cisco-ai-defense.github.io, read .
cisco-16 (vendor): On 2026-10-21, Cisco said enterprise administrators can set user- or group-based policy for which coding agents run on managed endpoints and which run only in a sandbox.
Quote: "Enterprise administrators can configure user or group-based policy to determine which coding agents can run on their managed endpoints"
Source: blogs.cisco.com, read .
cisco-17 (vendor): On 2026-10-21, Cisco said every block, approval and decision is recorded with the agent, sandbox and policy behind it and can be sent to Splunk or any OpenTelemetry backend.
Quote: "Every block, approval and decision is recorded along with the agent, the sandbox and the policy behind it, and can be sent to Splunk or any OpenTelemetry backend."
Source: blogs.cisco.com, read .
cisco-18 (vendor): DefenseClaw observability documentation lists OTLP, Splunk, Galileo, file and webhook destinations for logs, traces and metrics.
Quote: "goes to the destinations you add: an OpenTelemetry (OTLP) collector, Splunk, Galileo, a file, or a webhook."
Source: cisco-ai-defense.github.io, read .
cisco-21 (vendor): Cisco's open-source MCP Scanner combines the AI Defense inspect API, YARA rules and LLM-based analysis to detect malicious MCP tools.
Quote: "The MCP Scanner combines Cisco AI Defense inspect API, YARA rules and LLM-based analysis to detect malicious MCP tools."
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-22 (vendor): The MCP Scanner scans a server's tools, prompts, resources and instructions.
Quote: "Scan MCP tools, prompts, resources, and server instructions for security findings"
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-23 (vendor): The MCP Scanner can scan PyPI packages for hidden behavior inside a Docker sandbox before they are used.
Quote: "Download and scan PyPI packages inside a Docker sandbox with behavioral analysis."
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-24 (vendor): The MCP Scanner has a known-configs mode that scans servers from well-known MCP client config locations on the machine.
Quote: "scan servers from well-known client config locations on this machine"
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-25 (vendor): The MCP Scanner README names Windsurf, Cursor, Claude and VS Code as the clients whose config paths it reads.
Quote: "Scan well-known MCP config paths (Windsurf, Cursor, Claude, VS Code)"
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-26 (vendor): The MCP Scanner can scan a remote MCP server over SSE or streamable HTTP when given its URL.
Quote: "remote**: scan a remote MCP server (SSE or streamable HTTP)."
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-27 (vendor): The MCP Scanner runs as a stand-alone command-line tool or a REST API server, installed with uv.
Quote: "Run scanner as a stand-alone CLI tool or REST API server"
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-28 (vendor): The MCP Scanner README documents a static mode for CI/CD pipelines and air-gapped environments.
Quote: "Scan pre-generated JSON files without live server connections - perfect for CI/CD pipelines and air-gapped environments"
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-29 (vendor): DefenseClaw documentation says its public website is the source of truth for install, configuration and operator workflows, and the code is Apache-2.0.
Quote: "is the source of truth for installation, setup, configuration, commands, and operator workflows"
Source: github.com, read .
cisco-30 (observed): The GitHub API lists the cisco-ai-defense/mcp-scanner repository as Apache-2.0 licensed with 1119 stars and a push on 2026-11-15.
Quote: "mcp-scanner |pushed 2026-11-15 |stars 1119 |license Apache-2.0"
Source: api.github.com, read .
cisco-31 (third-party): On 2026-03-23, SiliconANGLE reported DefenseClaw lets administrators block specific MCP servers, with block rules applied in two seconds without restarting agents.
Quote: "A permission management feature enables administrators to block specific MCP servers."
Source: siliconangle.com, read .
cisco-32 (third-party): SiliconANGLE quoted Cisco saying that blocking an MCP server removes its endpoint from the sandbox network allow-list so OpenShell denies all connections.
Quote: "When you block an MCP server, the endpoint is removed from the sandbox network allow-list and OpenShell denies all connections."
Source: siliconangle.com, read .
cisco-33 (third-party): SiliconANGLE reported developers can install DefenseClaw in about five minutes and that it scans MCP tools and plug-ins an agent uses.
Quote: "Cisco says developers can install DefenseClaw in about five minutes."
Source: siliconangle.com, read .
cisco-34 (vendor): Cisco says DefenseClaw scans skills, plugins and MCP servers at install, before they are allowed into the environment.
Quote: "it gets scanned before it is allowed into your environment."
Source: blogs.cisco.com, read .
cisco-35 (vendor): Cisco says DefenseClaw streams every scan result, block decision, tool call and alert as structured events.
The exact quote is on the source page.
Source: blogs.cisco.com, read .
cisco-36 (none-found): None found on 2026-11-16: a statement that DefenseClaw or the MCP Scanner inspects the arguments of an individual MCP tool call on the machine and blocks it; the docs name tool_call hooks for coding agents in general, not MCP tool calls specifically.
Source: cisco-ai-defense.github.io, read .
cisco-37 (third-party): SiliconANGLE reported DefenseClaw sends telemetry on the risks it finds to Splunk through a prepackaged connector.
Quote: "DefenseClaw sends telemetry about the cybersecurity risks that it finds to Splunk through a prepackaged connector."
Source: siliconangle.com, read .
cisco-38 (vendor): DefenseClaw documentation describes an enterprise edition that an administrator deploys with a package or an MDM and that users cannot turn off.
Quote: "the managed standalone profile an administrator deploys with a package or an MDM. Users can't turn it off."
Source: cisco-ai-defense.github.io, read .
cisco-41 (vendor): Cisco says its planned MCP gateway applies authorization policies across tools and blocks out-of-bounds agent actions, but also says the features are in development.
Quote: "the MCP gateway applies authorization policies consistently across tools and services."
Source: blogs.cisco.com, read .
cisco-56 (none-found): None found on 2026-11-16: a published price for Cisco AI Defense on its product page; the free Explorer Edition is announced but no paid list price was found.
Source: cisco.com, read .
cisco-57 (third-party): CRN reported that at RSAC 2026 Cisco introduced a free Explorer Edition of AI Defense for red teaming agents.
Quote: "Cisco also debuted updates to its AI Defense offering with the introduction of a free “Explorer Edition.”"
Source: crn.com, read .
cisco-58 (vendor): The AI Defense product page quotes Kent Noyes of World Wide Technology, a named customer voice.
Quote: "The adoption of AI exposes companies to new risks that traditional cybersecurity solutions don't address."
Source: cisco.com, read .
cisco-59 (none-found): None found on 2026-11-16: independent analyst coverage (Gartner, Forrester, IDC) or a funding round for AI Defense on the pages read; Cisco is a public company.
Source: cisco.com, read .
cisco-60 (third-party): SiliconANGLE covered the 2026-03-23 DefenseClaw release at RSAC 2026 and the Explorer Edition.
Quote: "The networking giant also released an open-source tool, DefenseClaw, that can scan AI agents for vulnerabilities."
Source: siliconangle.com, read .